W is for government

Tom Steinberg is a clever man, of course. When he says “Governments don’t have websites: governments are websites”, I think he’s wrong – but he’s a clever man, so at least he’s wrong in interesting ways.

“Increasingly, when I form a mental image of a branch of government in my head, what I see is the website.”

Really? When was the last time you looked at the Army’s website? Did you drive home tonight seeing only HTML, or did you keep your eyes on the road? Do you feel some confidence that a plane won’t crash on your head because you’ve checked on caa.co.uk?  Is the first thing you do in the morning is have a look on police.uk to see if you’ve been murdered in the night? No, Tom, your main interface to government is not through a web browser: it’s through something called everyday life, through the environment in which you live and breathe, in which you transact business, through the rules you observe or ignore.

“To [most] people, interacting with government already feels somewhat like interacting with Amazon.”

OK, so the key point is that word “interacting”. You’ve reduced all the stuff government does to create and sustain a great part of the environment you inhabit to a question of what it feels like, essentially, when you want something – either because something has gone wrong (you’re sick, the bins haven’t been emptied, the road has a pothole) or because you’re obliged to (you owe them money). If you only look at the aspect of government that is a little bit  like Amazon then it’s not a surprise if it looks like Amazon.

Now of course the slogan “governments are websites” is just a slogan, as the rest of Steinberg’s piece makes clear. What he say is that he doesn’t like government websites and he thinks public sector organisations don’t worry enough about the fact that their websites – particularly the transactional bits of their websites – are horrible. Fair enough. Or nearly fair enough. When I saw the slogan being repeated and retweeted (Steinberg said it first at SOCITM’s Building Perfect Council Websites 2012 event), it had an oddly nostalgic air to it. Its language reminded me of dotcom boomery and clicks not bricks and those heady days of e-everything. Do we even use websites any more? We use web pages and web services and bits of web functionality – but we experience them through searches, in apps, from links or QR codes. And yet public sector bodies, according to Steinberg, should be thinking more about  “their” websites.

There’s a whole lot of thinking about finding services against finding websites that’s really fascinating (and which Amazon, on the whole, doesn’t have to bother its pretty little head about). I don’t want to go to my local authority’s (hideous) website to check the bin delivery day: I want to Google “bin delivery day” and for my device, the apps, Google, and whoever else is needed all to get together to tell me when my bins will be emptied – full stop. Yet when the service goes horribly wrong and I want to know the names of the buggers who’ve been failing to empty my bins properly for the last year, I absolutely want to know the name of my councillor, her address, and how I can vote the lazy bugger out. In the former transaction, branding only gets in the way of telling me what I need to know. In the latter case, branding does something that it will probably never do for Jeff Bezos (no matter how good his politics may be): it enables democratic accountability. Weirdly, for the man behind “MySociety”, Steinberg’s article doesn’t even hint at the existence of democracy. Perhaps because it doesn’t fit into a slogan very well.

In the last part of his piece, Steinberg makes some very good points about governments (and agencies and local authorities). Essentially he is saying “The public sector should think more about its digital services and in order to do that they should have some senior people who understand the first thing about it”. That’s not a very snappy slogan, but at least it’s kind of reasonable. But please let’s not, by overselling the point and indulging in slogans, give space to the claim that Amazon has the answer to running the public sector.

Are we for responsibility?

I spent a day last week at The Guardian’s Managing Public Sector Information conference in London (hashtag #psi2011), and came away with head buzzing about transparency and open data.

It’s probably fair to say that the mood of the conference was a combination of vague approval – “transparency” is a little like apple pie, you can’t really argue with it as an idea – mingled with worry. Actually, perhaps that was only my mood. But it’s prompted me to think more about the worries.

Mike Martin led a session which I think probably had most attendees a little baffled. Well OK, it left me a little baffled. But what I took from it was one key message (and my apologies to Mike if I misrepresent him at all here).

Technology changes in the promulgation of ideas – from the invention of moveable type to typesetting to web publication – have involved constant renegotiation of the roles that we describe as “author”, “editor” and “publisher”. This negotiation has taken place within the marketplace, the law, and popular understanding, and each time leads to different views of the value those roles contribute (financial, social, etc), of their liabilities and responsibilities, and of their their role in giving authority to content.

So what does it mean when we talk about public bodies “publishing” data? What responsibilities and liabilities are involved? What authority does the name of the body as “publisher” bestow on the data? To whom does the data belong once it is published?

Do these questions matter? Well, I suspect they do, partly because of two thoughts that came up during the day.

The first related to that idea of “authority”. Does the emphasis on publishing data as an end in itself reflect a rather naive belief in the objectivity and authority of data against other kinds of information? Do we really believe the figures for exam passes at a college represent a better way of selecting a college, as against the anecdotal and experience-based views we come across in conversations at the school gates (or on FaceBook)? Do we really think that crime maps give us a better picture of the experience of crime in our area than local gossip and maybe a local news-sheet does? I realise that these questions don’t imply that we shouldn’t have access to*both the data and the anecdotal, of course. But will the weight carried by each of the two words “government data” overpower other voices?

The second point came in a presentation from Pat Ellison of Barnardo’s. Barnardo’s work is frequently paid for under contract to local authorities. Pat explained how voluntary sector organisations like hers work with people who are frequently vulnerable and almost always facing hugely difficult situations. So there needs to be a high level of trust by clients of the voluntary organisation involved, trust which must sometimes be built on precisely the fact that they are not state agents. Pat explained that Barnardo’s and others have no issue with the principle that they must account to the authority for the work which they have funded: this is not completely unproblematic, but can be managed. It’s when that data is to be made public that things change somewhat. It’s not that there’s a threat to individual privacy – at least, one hopes and assumes not. The question is, is this a case where transparency, far from encouraging trust, actually erodes it? Will people have quite the same trustful approach to sharing very sensitive personal information with an organisation when they know that their data (however well anonymised) is to be put in the public domain? Do we have the right to re-use the personal information of people who, by the nature of things, are unlikely themselves to be able to access or take advantage of the neatly-packaged CSV files which document their misery? (Please note that I am paraphrasing Pat’s presentation wildly; don’t blame her if I’m exaggerating for effect.)

Of course, these are edge-cases. I’m not suggesting that they throw the whole transparency project into doubt. But they do suggest to me that we need some kind of classification scheme by which to distinguish different kinds of “public data” and the differing degrees of authority they carry – and that we in the public sector need to recognise our responsibilities as a publisher as we push the data out there.

Which is the idea I’ll explore, I hope, in another blog.

Seeing through transparency?

So the UK Government has published Departmental spend reports, amid much fanfare over the unprecedented opening up of government and so on (the Scottish Government got there first , as it happens).

Cabinet Office Minister Francis Maude set out the purpose of the exercise: “I want the public to hold us to account for what we do“, and the Government has conjured up an image of a nation of “armchair auditors” who will probe and analyse this data until every story is unearthed and every scrap of waste is excised.

I’m sure that some of said auditors are beavering away. I’m sure that some stories will emerge. So far, all I’ve seen is a few sniggers at the “revelation” of a £26k training bill for training Cabinet Office staff to have “difficult conversations”, and some similar fluff.

Am I alone in being sceptical about the consequences – intended or unintended – of this kind of “transparency”?

There’s something in that term “armchair auditors” that rings alarm bells. Because these spend figures are available to real, professional auditors who regularly expose the (perhaps relatively few) instances of poor judgement, gross inefficiency and downright fraud that goes on in Government. And since they have access to much more than the raw data that is being pumped out, they probably have a better understanding of what value is being delivered by the spend in question. Indeed, I know of no organisation, public or private, in which scrutiny of detailed spend reports by senior managers, still less by shareholders, is held to be a model of good governance. Even at my pretty abject level in the Great Chain of Being,  transaction reports are a small part of the picture that allows me to manage my unit’s work.

So the result is more likely to be the kind of “story” that the press seemed to find in the “difficult conversations” workshop (even the Guardian couldn’t resist, referring to that workshop as “lingering waste”, as though it was something nasty and smelly left in a desk drawer that Gordon Brown should have emptied on his way out). Lacking context, and caring less, the media can focus on anything that looks wacky, creative, “politically-correct”, and most especially on anything that looks even remotely fun, and “hold Ministers’ feet to the fire” until they use those same feet to stamp on any such activity. The most “difficult conversations” Cabinet Office civil servants may be having is trying to explain to Mr Maude why £26k may actually have been pretty good value in the circumstances…

This makes me think of last weekend’s furore over the outing of civil servant Sarah Baskerville (@baskers) for tweeting at and about her work in Whitehall. The twitterati were outraged. Bloggers (there were quite a few) argued that this kind of attack will, and is probably designed to, scare public servants away from revealing themselves to be human beings with feelings and hangovers, and discourage them from using social media for fear of ending up pilloried in the Mail.

Will the release of spend data produce the same kind of self-defensive caution among public servants? A civil service paralysed at the thought that anything but the most rigorous and explicit orthodoxy in their spending habits will leave them exposed and hung out to dry? Yes, almost certainly. After all, civil servants are a pretty cautious lot at the best of times. Will this be good for public services, the public purse, or the public generally? Doubtful.

Don’t get me wrong – I do believe that transparency is important. The point is, though, that transparency can be dangerous without engagement. If the processes, conversations and decisions of our public services are really to become transparent, then public servants need to have the tools (and that means the technical resources, the skills, and the backing) to contextualise, to consult, to explain, and at the end of the day to defend, their own actions. Otherwise the release of post hoc data will only encourage witch-hunts and scare stories which reinforce the view that public servants are, literally, a bunch of wasters.

But perhaps that’s the point?

Information overload: it’s not just filter failure

I posted previously on Clay Shirkey’s assertion that there is no information overload, just filter failure. I pointed out that filtering is only half of the attention management picture (pulling information forward is the other part).

It is not that there’s a lot of information; it is that there’s a lot more information that we are expected to read than we have time to read it in … And this is why Email Overload is a problem and RSS feed overload is much less so: there is an expectation (express or implied) that you must go through all the mail in your Inbox; there is no such expectation for an RSS reader.

Read more at knowledgeforward.wordpress.com